999 Central Avenue, Suite 100-D
Woodmere, NY 11598

(516) 268-7077


Apple! Patented LTE ain’t for free!

Apple has been ordered to pay $506 million for infringing patents held by PanOptis says an Eastern District of Texas federal jury.

Optis Wireless patents, that related to the use of LTE technology in the iPhone, Apple Watch, and iPad. One of Apple’s chief arguments was to analyze the phone and you will see there is no infringement. Apple argued compatibility with LTE was not evidence of infringement.

Optis contended that Apple infringed and refused to enter a licensing agreement. This, according to the company, was in compliance with its “Fair, Reasonable, and Non-Discriminatory” obligations. Optis argued that it “repeatedly” negotiated with Apple, but the negotiations were unsuccessful.

The patents in the case:

  • “Method and Apparatus for Transmitting and Receiving Shared Control Channel Message in a Wireless Communication System Using Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access”
  • “Method for Transmitting and Receiving Control Information through PDCCH”
  • “Mobile Station Apparatus and Random Access Method”
  • “System and Method for Channel Estimation in a Delay Diversity Wireless Communication System”
  • “Method for Transmitting Uplink Signals”
  • “Mode switching between SU-MIMO and MU-MIMO.”
  • “Control channel signaling using a common signaling field for transport format and redundancy version”

Verdict said Apple must pay $506 million to Optis for past sales.

Contact Us

    sidebar image

    Rubinstein Law Firm

    The Rubinstein Law Firm proudly serves all of New York for divorce and other state matters and the whole country on intellectual property related matters.


    • What kind of cases do you handle?
    • Family Law Cases such as:

      – Divorce- both contested and uncontested, same sex and gray divorce

      – Custody

      – Support

      – Alimony/ Maintenance

      – Equitable Distribution

    • Intellectual Property cases such as:

      – Patents

      – Copyrights

      – Trademarks, Service Marks and Trade Dress

      – Data Privacy

      – Transactional work such as: Terms and Conditions, IP registration and enforcements and cease and desists

      – Any other IP related matter.

    • How much will my matter cost?
      • Our firm has a different philosophy than virtually any other, we try to close cases quickly. We recognize if you are happy, you will refer us clients. In most matters, it will depend on how complicated the facts and/or legal issues are and how willing the parties are to settle.
    • How does your firm have two differing specialties?
      • We spend a lot of money, time and resources to remain experts in our respective fields. Join the parties and opposing counsels who are baffled by our expertise in both areas.

    Request A Consultation