999 Central Avenue, Suite 100-D
Woodmere, NY 11598

(516) 268-7077


Guaranteed Copyright Failure, Claim You Forgot You Erased Rights on an Image

Oppenheimer v. Johnson, No. 1:19-CV-00240-MR, 2020 WL 4227472 (W.D.N.C. July 23, 2020).

On August 13, 2019, Plaintiff Oppenheimer sued Cullowhee, LLC for copyright infringement. Plaintiff is a photographer and makes his photos available online for print and licensing through his website. All of his photos display his copyright information.

Defendants wanted to advertise their property for rent near Western Carolina University and uploaded Plaintiff’s photograph to 2 URLs for that purpose. Defendants removed Plaintiff’s copyright and notice prior to the upload. Clearly, Defendants knew the photos were copyrighted and disregarded that uploading here would be infringement. Thus, Defendants who defaulted in this matter, clearly their actions were willful.

Moreover, the DMCA prohibits a person, to “distribute” work “knowing that copyright management information has been removed or altered”. The DMCA requires that the action be taken by a person “knowing or … having reasonable grounds to know that it will induce, enable, facilitate, or conceal an infringement.”

Thus, the court found that their removal and uploading was proof enough to find for the Plaintiff.

Contact Us

    sidebar image

    Rubinstein Law Firm

    The Rubinstein Law Firm proudly serves all of New York for divorce and other state matters and the whole country on intellectual property related matters.


    • What kind of cases do you handle?
    • Family Law Cases such as:

      – Divorce- both contested and uncontested, same sex and gray divorce

      – Custody

      – Support

      – Alimony/ Maintenance

      – Equitable Distribution

    • Intellectual Property cases such as:

      – Patents

      – Copyrights

      – Trademarks, Service Marks and Trade Dress

      – Data Privacy

      – Transactional work such as: Terms and Conditions, IP registration and enforcements and cease and desists

      – Any other IP related matter.

    • How much will my matter cost?
      • Our firm has a different philosophy than virtually any other, we try to close cases quickly. We recognize if you are happy, you will refer us clients. In most matters, it will depend on how complicated the facts and/or legal issues are and how willing the parties are to settle.
    • How does your firm have two differing specialties?
      • We spend a lot of money, time and resources to remain experts in our respective fields. Join the parties and opposing counsels who are baffled by our expertise in both areas.

    Request A Consultation